Questionable Moment: Potter Gets Away With It (4 comments)
twp3pf2


Posts: 29

Registered:
Nov 2006
Questionable Moment: Potter Gets Away With It
posted Tuesday, December 09, 2008 - 05:25 AM (#46162)
You HAVE seen the SNL alternate ending, right? The one where Uncle Billy remembers what he did with the money and they all go over to Potter's as a mob and beat the stuffing out of him? It was beautiful.
--
I'm not an archaeologist, but I play one on the DS.
Locked profile
WeDo


Posts: 7

Registered:
Apr 2007
I've got a different BOO-HOO moment (Score: 1)
posted Tuesday, December 09, 2008 - 07:21 AM (#46167)

"To my brother, George: the richest man in town." I lose it there every year.

Wendy


Locked profile
dstroupfsu


Posts: 2

Registered:
Dec 2008
Re: Questionable Moment: Potter Gets Away With It (Score: 1)
posted Tuesday, December 09, 2008 - 08:09 AM (#46168)

Here is a link to the SNL Alternate ending, enjoy!
http://hotair.com/archives/2006/12/23/video-its-a- wonderful-life-the-lost-ending/


Locked profile
Ikcor
Ikcor



From: Neither here, nor there

Posts: 21

Registered:
Jan 2008
Re: Questionable Moment: Potter Gets Away With It (Score: 1)
posted Tuesday, December 09, 2008 - 10:59 PM (#46172)
Here is the official link, in case that one goes down: http://www.hulu.com/watch/4267/saturday-night-live -its-a-wonderful-life-lost-ending [hulu.com]
Locked profile
bwross


Posts: 8

Registered:
Nov 2008
Re: Questionable Moment: Potter Gets Away With It (Score: 1)
posted Wednesday, December 10, 2008 - 12:56 AM (#46173)

Not resolving the money was the correct choice... it isn't required (George's financial problems are resolved without it in a way that's more supportive of the message) and extend the resolution longer than needed.

Modern films often make the mistake of having overly long resolutions. A modern version would probably feature an additional 5-10 minutes of "the next morning" with everyone saying "Hi" to George as he walks down the street, Potter being dragged off to jail, and a shot of Clarence flying around heaven talking to the angels. Essentially a lot of pointless things, when the best resolutions are short (look at North by Northwest... it goes from hanging off a cliff to the end screen in seconds, with nothing wasted). The worst part of all would be seeing Potter get his comeuppance as that would detract completely from the message of the film... it is not a film about the Baileys versus Potter, it's George Bailey versus himself.

It's also better to leave things open... with things continuing on, George never getting out of Bedford Falls, doing his best to better the community and prevent an $8000 stronger Potter from taking over everything, the only difference being that George now realizes how big his role is in the world even if he doesn't get to see everything and build all those hundred story high skyscrapers and mile long bridges. If Potter was given his comeuppance, that all sort of falls apart... the villain is gone and George has no opposition, a simple random act of Uncle Billy losing the money is all that was ever required to get a perfect happy ending where George is suddenly free to do all the things he wanted to do without ever having to care about Bedford Falls ever again. The message loses impact if the fight were to end... George would have his epiphany after everything was pretty much already done.


Locked profile
Threshold:  Locked
The Fine Print: The above comments are owned by whoever posted them. The Sheldon site is not responsible for them. However, if you suspect a post has been spammed by a person or 'bot, or that illegal of offensive posts need removal, contact your friendly neighborhood cartoonist.

forums

welcome! please login or register.